Home / General / Bear Baiting Vs. Spot and Stalk Bear Hunting

Bear Baiting Vs. Spot and Stalk Bear Hunting

Most western hunters know and agree that managing predators is very important when it comes to the North American model of wildlife management. Bears play a big role in the predator pie chart for fawn and calf predation and there are many studies out there that show this. That specifically is why I have the desire to go bear hunting every spring. Between wolves, grizzlies, lions and the black bears out there, I want to save as many calves and fawns as possible! Studies also show that mature boars play the biggest role in calf and fawn predation and are known to “hunt” for calves and fawns. There have been many displays of this dating back to films by Gordon Eastman as well. 

There are three methods in which you can harvest a bear in the western states, the most common are baiting and spot and stalk. The third method of bear management is using hound dogs, which is probably the most productive. However, just a few states allow the use of dogs, the first that come to mind are Idaho and some areas in Utah. 

All three methods are drastically different but the cool thing is that there is a method for every type of hunter out there and I don’t believe any of them are wrong! Let me first say that hunting with hounds and over bait are great management tools. They really up the ante when it comes to predator control. In addition, there are many areas that are too thick, making spot and stalk hunting nearly impossible. When it comes to baiting some people say it isn’t fair chase. I agree with this, kind of. 

Bears are smart animals and giant smart old bruins don’t just come strolling into the bait once they’ve found it. Many are nocturnal and it’s very difficult to harvest a good one over bait. A great thing about bear baiting is it is an excellent way to introduce kids to the outdoors and allows them to observe bears being bears! This is an excellent tool to help spark interest in kids at a young age when so many things are pulling at them in this crazy world that we live in. 

Lastly, let’s talk spot and stalk hunting. This is the method I choose because it is the most difficult and exciting in my opinion. The reason I love bowhunting is to challenge myself and to get close! Spot and stalk bear hunting with a bow is a rush and is hard to beat when it comes to a springtime hunt in the lower 48. Montana is probably the best state for spot and stalk hunting as baiting is not legal there and trophy quality combined with a majority of color phases makes for a hunt that should be on the top of any bear hunters list.


No matter which method you choose for hunting spring bears the important thing to remember is that you’re contributing to effective and scientifically proven wildlife management. As I’ve said, I prefer spot and stalk but that’s just me, what’s your preferred method for hunting spring black bears? 



About Dan Pickar

Avatar photo

Check Also

Wicked Colorado Winter & Tag Reductions

Across much of the western portions of the Colorado Rockies, and especially the northwest corner …

Horses & Winter: Too Much For Western Wildlife?

The letter below came through my email this morning. I’ll not divulge who wrote it …


  1. The old timer on the mountain told me a story of how they would set out propane tanks and let the gas leak out slowly to bring bears in. Every year they would kill several bears within 200 yards of camp. Fact or fiction?

    Fresh snow this morning anyone else be so lucky?

  2. Spot and stalk I can’t stand still

  3. Well Dan what about the elders who can’t walk much any more or the light weight 12 to 16 that don’t have the stamina for stalking. The comment about spot and stalk is a young mans ego talking. All of you that agree about the spot and stalk should quit confusing the control issue with beating your chest. I know I had bear and lion dogs now that is a young mans sport. I would like to see 12 to 16yrs and over 60 to be able to bait nation wide.

    • As I stated, all 3 methods are great and you have the luxury in picking out what method suits you. Hope you get out hunting this spring!

  4. Bearded hunter.

    FYI.Black Bear baiting has been banned in Wyoming and Idaho. Just saw that on the news here in Idaho 2 days ago. 3 liberal activist groups got together and used grizzly bears as there angle to get a judge to side with them

    • Not true but Judge Dale did do is “allow” the lawsuit to be heard. But she did cite lawsuits that have already set the precedent for the ban NOT to happen. I don’t think it will go through but activists will not stop and we need to keep fighting for conservation!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.